Surviving A Multi-Opponent Attack
Maneuvering For Advantage: Basics
by Christopher Caile
Editor's note: This is the third of a series of articles
exploring principles, tactics and techniques that can be used when confronted
with multiple attackers.
I believe that proper movement is the most critical element of defense
against multiple attackers. It is also the least understood.
I see many martial arts books and videos of experts demonstrating their
defenses against multiple attackers. The master stands in the center,
turning this way and that to defeat each successive attacker. It's inspiring.
It makes you think if you just study his art and learn his knowledge you
might someday become invincible too.
Don't believe it. It usually doesn't work. On the street attackers aren't
respectful, they don't wait their turn, and they don't keep their distance.
They close in from all sides like a garbage compactor - squish.
I'm not sure if it is a lack of understanding, the difficulty of explanation,
or the limitations of video, but the most important element is missing
in these books and videos -- that of getting out of positions of maximum
danger and moving to a position of advantage.
The first part of proper movement is a basic vocabulary of stances and
movement patterns that enable your action. These are the building blocks
that enable you to take back some control in a multi-opponent attack that
has gotten out of control.
Yin & Yang Of Action
Central to the stance and movement patterns discussed below are two counterbalancing
1 - Do Unto Others
A logical outgrowth of the two principles discussed in Part
2 of this article (Indomitable Spirit and Total Commitment)
is not to be defensive, but to be offensive. That means to take the initiative
whenever possible (discussed briefly in Part
When you react defensively you cede timing and initiative to your attackers.
If you wait to react, this gives time to your opponents to circle or close
in on you.
A good friend, Oscar Ratti (co-author of "Aikido and The Dynamic
Sphere" and "Secrets of the Samurai"), said it well when
he observed: "In combat against others, always be on the offensive.
Take the initiative. Don't even think about defense. Even thinking about
it slows you down. Instead, create chaos and havoc in them first. Do unto
others before they do it to you."
However, just being aggressive and attacking is not enough. You should
move to maximize your position (the subject of the following article).
Equally, your attacks and moves should not be so wild or foolish as to
2 - Don't Do It To Yourself
The flip side of attacking or taking the initiative is not to endanger
yourself needlessly - the yin to temper the yang.
While there are no fixed rules in facing multi-attackers, playing the
percentages always has advantage. You may get away with something that
also momentarily makes you vulnerable or exposed, but too often the odds
catch up with you. If you gamble and throw the dice, you may win big sometimes,
but most often you lose. On the street the consequences can be more severe.
So avoid rolling the dice. Here are a few cautions.
Be careful with kicks. Any kick momentarily freezes you on one
leg and can slow forward movement. You
are also less stable. If pushed or grabbed you can be unbalanced or thrown
to the ground, so keep kicks fast and pull them back quickly. Also combine
them with other techniques. High and spinning kicks are especially dangerous.
You can sometimes get away with them but don't make them your habit. You
expose your groin and the kicking leg can be caught. The kicker also leans
backward. This moves his body backward and exposes it to potential attack
from behind. This is the reason that in most old karate kata the kicks
were kept low (at least in the original kata versions). (1)
Before being attacked don't assume a defensive preparatory stance
with raised arms and wait for the action to begin. Boxers or karate practitioners
do this at the start of a match to be fair and let the opponent be prepared.
This isn't your goal. It wastes time and signals defense. If an attack
hasn't started, attack first and/or move to a better position.
Don't fight from wide horse stance (or a modified one). This can
be a dangerous fighting position against multiple attackers since you
are standing sideways with the legs spread. This needlessly exposes the
groin to attacks not only from the front but the sides, while also exposing
the back. Quick movement to the sides is also more difficult. It is also
a defensive position. Your opponents see it and your own psyche knows
too -- two negatives when your actions have to be totally offensive. You
are also not positioned for total commitment or aggressive initiative.
The stance is useful in some situations, however. These will be discussed
below. But keep the stance limited to special situations.
Minimize weighting or standing on one foot. This can limit mobility
and reduce stability. In multi-attacker confrontations mobility and stability
are prime, thus any position that roots you on one foot should be minimized
since it reduces these factors.
(a) Cat stances can be momentarily useful in some situations, but don't
stay there. You can use them as transitions, to create momentary space
in one direction or a platform to kick from, but don't linger -- they
are defensive and they inhibit movement.
(b) Likewise lifting the knee to block a kick is sometimes useful but
it can also be dangerous. This is a favorite response of grapplers who
fakes a low kick to your legs and then charge in low to take you off your
feet. My housemate in Buffalo was a full-contact Ultimate Fighter and
grappler who used this move to perfection against me -- bang. At first,
I couldn't figure out what was happening. He would kick, I would lift
my leg and there I would be flat on my back with him all over me.
Eventually I found that, against a grappler (percentage wise), it was
more effective to pivot out of the way of a low roundhouse kick, pull
back the front foot out of the way, or shift to the side or backward at
an angle with a simultaneous down block.
(c) While punching try not to plant your forward foot. While this can
be useful in delivering maximum power forward, it also roots you and shifts
weight on to your forward foot. As a result, you lose mobility.
Tools of The Trade
Principles, tactics, and techniques are all good, but you have to tie
them in with a strategy that can get your where you need to be and get
you away from the most dangerous situations. Here we discuss the tools
of the trade -- the basics of standing, moving and turning. In the next
section of this article we show how to put them together so you can move
to a position of advantage.
Whatever happens or develops in a multiple attack you will probably start
from a normal standing or walking position (sitting or lying positions
are outside the scope of this series of articles). If you are walking
and attacked everything is sudden and you are into it before you can think.
Standing can be a little different. You have probably stopped walking
or you are standing as someone approaches, or is there next to you.
A standing position has many advantages. While high, and thus less than
perfectly stable, this stance enables you to move quickly in any direction
and the legs are close enough together to protect the groin from many
kicks, or knees. (2)
When action begins you always want to protect your head, a favorite target
of attackers. A common tactic to avoid a surprise hit is to say something
and talk with your hands up front between you and the closest attacker.
This will not seem aggressive but will allow a split second block or a
quick offensive technique since your hands should already be more than
half way to your opponent. This is not a defensive stance (discussed below).
Once things start, protect your face and head as you move. You also want
to keep low and have your feet under you. This also protects your groin.
You can take long steps to move, but don't keep one once you in close
to an attacker. Here keep your stance narrow. Some experts suggest keeping
the rear leg angled slightly outward so as to be able to quickly shift
to the side. (3) I like to keep the front
foot angled in slightly to give a little extra groin protection.
There are also several patterns or principles of movement you will find
optimal in multi-attacker situation -- the quick advance, the slide or
angle past, the bump and run, the zig zag movement, and the pivot. (4)
Move forward quickly, not backward (just like in most karate kata)
so you can take a position of advantage or achieve an objective. Often
this means moving into an attacker to attack, or to interrupt an attack
coming at you before it has fully developed (jamming). Being close also
can forestall a second attack from an opponent's foot or other fist. In
the process of moving forward you also create space behind you and thus
avoid a sudden hit from behind. The diagram below represents this situation.
The three circles at top represent a defender between two attackers. Both
attackers can reach him. Below, the defender advances towards one attacker,
thereby creating a momentary barrier of space at his back.
This doesn't mean you can never back up -- retreating can give you some
momentary space, and thus protection. But if you continue backing up,
you put yourself at serious risk since your attackers are probably advancing
too. This means you have given up the initiative to them. In the process
they might get closer, position around you or you might be maneuvered
into a place that limits further retreat.
When you move forward for any distance, do so quickly. Shuffling forward
like a boxer (or most martial arts competitors) is great for small adjustments,
but too slow over more than a few feet. So if you want to move more than
a single step take strides, one foot in front of another similar to the
way you move in kata. And it helps to keep low and centered so you can
punch or block, grab or control. (5)
An important corollary of the quick advance is to angle past an
opponent, or if a tight place, to slide around him.
Forward movement if angled can get you to the side or behind the opponent
-- a space where his weapons can't get at you and from where you can more
easily control, throw or take down your opponent. This is shown in the
two drawings below. At left, an attacker is preparing to club the defender.
The blow is avoided, however, by stepping forward and angling to the side
of the opponent (right drawing).
When is a tight place, such as in a corner with an attacker close, it
is useful to slide your forward foot at an angle past your opponents front
foot and sink into a low stable position (horse stance) at his side. My
boxing coach often demonstrated this type of quick slide around the edge
of an opponent who was trying to corner you in the ropes. As part of this
move he used his forward arm like a windshield wiper (outside block fashion)
against the rear of an opponent's shoulder to help propel himself around
to the outside.
The bump and run is a second corollary of the quick advance. This
is when you move forward quickly to freeze or make your opponent move
Sometimes you don't actually have to make contact. Just a quick threatening
forward move can freeze someone or force a quick retreat so you can get
around them. Another scenario is when one attacker is standing close right
in front of others. Here a quick forceful push, bump, or kick forces the
attacker backward. Because others are standing right behind, there is
little or no room to step back. Legs will get tied up. The front attacker
will often stumble, or at least take a second to regain balance. Other
attackers standing behind him will also be momentarily blocked. (6)
This can buy you room to maneuver as well as precious time.
Zig Zaging is like broken field running in football. Moving one
direction and then quickly veering off in another to avoid opponents,
or to make space. Examples discussed in the next installment of this article
will illustrate this movement.
Pivoting and turning. Quick pivoting motions can quickly get you
out of the path of an attack or away from an attacker. Think like a basketball
player who quickly pivots so he can shoot. In one-on-one situations the
defender often parries/deflects while:
(a) Pivoting back --Moving one leg back and to the side while narrowing
the body -- a sort of opening the door to let an attack or an attacker
(b) Pivoting away - Pivoting 90 degrees or 180 degrees on the forward
foot to get to the side of an opponent or an attack, or to move to position
of advantage to the side.
(c) Pivoting or turning in order to control and lead an attack or attacker's
body or to throw or take down an opponent. Also to control the energy
of multiple grabbers.
(d) Pivoting to slide or move past an opponent who is crowding you.
(e) Spinning when attacked to deflect strikes or kicks.
In the next installment of this series we will discuss putting your tools,
strategy and tactics together as part of various movement strategies.
(1) This can be a confusing point. Many
people would say, "but even in many of the old kata people kick high."
That is true, but people now perform kata to look good, to demonstrate
their physical capability and to impress judges. This wasn't always so.
The kata has also been changed. For example, let's look at Pinan #4 .
This same technique is also part of the much older kata Kanku (also known
as Kusanku in Okinawa). In Pinan #4 the practitioner kicks to the side
with the blade of his foot (side kick) accompanied with a back fist that
rises from the waist level vertically and moves in a half circle to strike
with two knuckles (furi-uchi). This is done to both sides. In the oldest
versions of the kata, this technique was different. Instead there was
a body pivot to the side and a simultaneous middle level front kick and
strike with the arm traveling from the waist in a horizontal circular
path and striking with the little finger side of a clenched fist (tettsui).
When the Pinan kata was taken to Japan as part of karate things changed
(even the name Pinan was changed in many styles to Heian). Sometime in
the late 1930's this technique also changed. When I first learned the
kata in the late 1950's in the United States (studying a mixture of Kempo
and Shotokan karate), the side kick and back fist were done very quickly,
the side kick whipped out (to midsection or chest level) and pulled back
so the technique could progress into an elbow smash (the next technique).
Everything was done very fast. It was done the same way in Japan in Kyokushin
karate in the early 1960's. Sometime by the late 1970's or early 1980's
the technique styles changed again in some styles (I was then studying
Seido Karate). Now the side kick was no longer whipped out and retreated.
Instead the side kick was thrust out and held for a moment. It looked
great and competition judges loved it. Some practitioners could kick high
above their head and hold the extended kick position. A lot of kata competitions
were won with this type of gymnastic flexibility. This execution, however,
is far cry from the original technique and further divorced from functional
execution. It should be stated, however, that many styles still practice
versions of Pinan #4 and Kanku (Kusanku) using the original technique
with the front kick aimed at a low target.
(2) This is the reason that almost all
karate kata start from this position, a natural stance from which a defender
can easily move in any direction, pivot or turn to the side, drop down
or move using a variety of stances.
(3) In aikido, for example the back foot
it often angled 90 degrees to the side. This way the body is able to quickly
move to the side. If the back foot is angled forward, movement to the
side can be slightly slowed because most people will turn their foot slightly
before moving and this takes time. Interestingly, in some karate styles,
some stances also employ the back foot at 90 degrees to the side, or even
turned to the rear. This is related to footnote #4 (directly below).
(4) I have not discussed here a concept
of movement that can reduce response time and add speed (of movement)
over short distances. It was unique among the Samurai and was one distinct
element that provided his edge, and enabled almost unbelievable feats
-- that of dropping your weight into steps instead of moving it forward
as most everyone does while stepping. But the topic was avoided here because
it is so foreign and difficult to master. It requires a re-education of
movement. It has also been lost to most modern martial arts. You still
see it in a few old styles of karate and in such arts, as daito-ryu aikijujutsu,
and swordsmanship (kenjutsu). Other arts, such as aikido, employ the same
concepts in some movement, but not in others.
(5) A karate practitioner (as well as taekwondo
and kung fu) here might think of using front leaning stances, while aikido
and jujutsu practitioners might be a little higher, taking one quick large
step or two alternate steps forward just like in practice. This is striding,
not running. It is more controlled and your arms are free to punch or
do other techniques. You can also change direction, or pivot, or pull
back one foot (cat stance) to create a little space in front of you and/or
to kick. The body can be turned to the side (short horse stance) to evade
or move to the side.
One of the fastest forward movement over distance (10-15 feet or more)
I have ever seen is the stance and movement seen in many kata, such as
Pinan One, where there are three explosive steps with punches. Shotokan
karate stylists often use this type of quick stepping to close in on competitors.
Likewise some Chinese kung fu systems, especially pak mei (white eyebrow),
moves this way with incredible, almost overpowering speed while punching.
(6) An good example of this type tripping
was seen in a demonstration. In the early 1970's one day I accompanied
Shihan Tadashi Nakamura (then head of the Kyokushin's North American Organization)
to Madison Square Garden where he was to give a demonstration of karate.
Appearing just after him was Bruce Lee, who demonstrated his one inch
punch. He lined up five or six people right in front of each other and
put a chair just behind the last person in line. Standing in front, he
then punched the first man, who fell into the second, who fell into the
next until the last man fell into the chair and tipped backward. It looked
amazing but in reality everyone was set up to easily trip over the next,
so it was difficult to really judge the amount of power generated. In
contrast, Nakamura demonstrated breaking through four one inch boards
(without spacers) held by an associate using just his fingertips (nukite).
I: Interfering With And Avoiding An Impending Attack
Part 2 Principles & Tactics
Part 3 Maneuvering For Advantage: Basics
4 Maneuvering For Advantage: Putting it all together
5:Maneuvering For Advantage: More Scenarios
About the Author:
Christopher Caile is the Founder and Editor-In-Chief of FightingArts.com.
He has been a student of the martial arts for over 40 years and holds
a 6th degree black belt in Seido Karate and has experience in judo, aikido,
diato-ryu, boxing and several Chinese fighting arts. He is also a long-term
student of one branch of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Qigong. He is a
personal disciple of the qi gong master and teacher of acupuncture Dr.
Zaiwan Shen (M.D., Ph.D.) and is Vice-President of the DS International
Chi Medicine Association. In Buffalo, NY, he founded the Qi gong Healing
Institute and The Qi Medicine Association at the State University of New
York at Buffalo. He has also written on Qi gong and other health topics
in a national magazine, the Holistic Health Journal and had been filmed
for a prospective PBS presentation on Alternative Medicine. Recently he
contributed a chapter on the subject to an award winning book on alternative
medicine, "Resources Guide To Alternative Health" produced
by Health Inform.